Sensing pedestrian flows for real-time assessment of non-pharmaceutical policy interventions during the COVID-19 pandemic
Main Article Content
Abstract
Introduction
To combat and mitigate the transmission of the SARS-CoV-2 virus, reducing the number of social contacts within a population is highly effective. Non-pharmaceutical policy interventions, e.g. stay-at-home orders, closing schools, universities, and (non-essential) businesses, are expected to decrease pedestrian flows in public areas, leading to reduced social contacts. The extent to which such interventions show the targeted effect is often measured retrospectively by surveying behavioural changes. Approaches that use data generated through mobile phones are hindered by data confidentiality and privacy regulations and complicated by selection effects. Furthermore, access to such sensitive data is limited. However, a complex pandemic situation requires a fast evaluation of the effectiveness of the introduced interventions aiming to reduce social contacts. Location-based sensor systems installed in cities, providing objective measurements of spatial mobility in the form of pedestrian flows, are suited for such a purpose. These devices record changes in a population’s behaviour in real-time, do not have privacy problems as they do not identify persons, and have no selection problems due to ownership of a device.
Objective
This work aimed to analyse location-based sensor measurements of pedestrian flows in 49 metropolitan areas at 100 locations in Germany to study whether such technology is suitable for the real-time assessment of behavioural changes during a phase of several different pandemic-related policy interventions.
Methods
Spatial mobility data of pedestrian flows was linked with policy interventions using the date as a unique linkage key. Data was visualised to observe potential changes in pedestrian flows before or after interventions. Furthermore, differences in time series of pedestrian counts between the pandemic and the pre-pandemic year were analysed.
Results
The sensors detected changes in mobility patterns even before policy interventions were enacted. Compared to the pre-pandemic year, pedestrian counts were 85% lower.
Conclusions
The study illustrated the practical value of sensor-based real-time measurements when linked with non-pharmaceutical policy intervention data. This study’s core contribution is that the sensors detected behavioural changes before enacting or loosening non-pharmaceutical policy interventions. Therefore, such technologies should be considered in the future by policymakers for crisis management and policy evaluation.
Article Details
References
Struijs P, Braaksma B, Daas PJH. Official Statistics and Big Data. Big Data Soc. 2014;1(1):1–6. https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951714538417
Kim G-H, Trimi S, Chung J-H. Big-data Applications in the Government Sector. Commun ACM. 2014;57(3):78–85. https://doi.org/10.1145/2500873
Japec L, Lyberg L. Big Data Initiatives in Official Statistics. In: Hill CA, Biemer PP, Buskirk TD, Japec L, Kirchner A, Kolenikov S, et al., editors. Big Data Meets Survey Science. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons; 2020. p. 273–302. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118976357.ch9
Braaksma B, Zeelenberg K, De Broe S. Big Data in Official Statistics. In: Hill CA, Biemer PP, Buskirk TD, Japec L, Kirchner A, Kolenikov S, et al., editors. Big Data Meets Survey Science. Hoboken: John Wiley & Sons; 2020. p. 303–38. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118976357.ch10
Galesic M, Bruine de Bruin W, Dalege J, Feld SL, Kreuter F, Olsson H, et al. Human Social Sensing Is an Untapped Resource for Computational Social Science. Nature. 2021;595(7866):214–22. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41586-021-03649-2
European Commission. ESSnet Big Data I. 2016 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/cros/content/essnet-big-data_en
European Commission. ESSnet Big Data II. 2018 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/cros/content/essnet-big-data-0_en
Daas PJH, Puts MJ, Buelens B, van den Hurk PAM. Big Data as a Source for Official Statistics. J Off Stat. 2015;31(2):249–62. https://doi.org/10.1515/jos-2015-0016
Allin P. Opportunities and Challenges for Official Statistics in a Digital Society. Contemp Soc Sci. 2021;16(2):156–69. https://doi.org/10.1080/21582041.2019.1687931
Ljones O. Pandemic and Official Statistics; Some Comments on Recent COVID-19 Experiences. Stat J IAOS. 2020;36(2):285–90. https://doi.org/10.3233/SJI-200672
De Broe S, ten Bosch O, Puts M, Koren W, Henning F, Bakker J. How Official Statistics Can Help Prevent Emerging Infectious Diseases. Conference on New Techniques and Technologies for Statistics (NTTS 2021).
Giest S. Big Data for Policymaking: Fad or Fasttrack? Policy Sci. 2017;50(3):367–82. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11077-017-9293-1
Poel M, Meyer ET, Schroeder R. Big Data for Policymaking: Great Expectations, but with Limited Progress? Policy Internet. 2018;10(3):347–67. https://doi.org/10.1002/poi3.176
Aragona B, De Rosa R. Big Data in Policy Making. Math Popul Stud. 2019;26(2):107–13. https://doi.org/10.1080/08898480.2017.1418113
Wamsley D, Chin-Yee B. COVID-19, Digital Health Technology and the Politics of the Unprecedented. Big Data Soc. 2021;8(1):1–6. https://doi.org/10.1177/20539517211019441
Hantrais L, Allin P, Kritikos M, Sogomonjan M, Anand PB, Livingstone S, et al. COVID-19 and the Digital Revolution. Contemp Soc Sci. 2021;16(2):256–70. https://doi.org/10.1080/21582041.2020.1833234
Brauner JM, Mindermann S, Sharma M, Johnston D, Salvatier J, Gavenčiak T, et al. Inferring the Effectiveness of Government Interventions Against COVID-19. Science. 2021;371(6531):eabd9338. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abd9338
Nouvellet P, Bhatia S, Cori A, Ainslie KEC, Baguelin M, Bhatt S, et al. Reduction in Mobility and COVID-19 Transmission. Nat Commun. 2021;12(1090):1–9. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41467-021-21358-2
Pan Y, Darzi A, Kabiri A, Zhao G, Luo W, Xiong C, et al. Quantifying Human Mobility Behaviour Changes During the COVID-19 Outbreak in the United States. Sci Rep. 2020;10(20742):1–9. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-020-77751-2
Fatmi MR. COVID-19 Impact on Urban Mobility. J Urban Manag. 2020;9(3):270–5. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jum.2020.08.002
Anke J, Francke A, Schaefer L-M, Petzoldt T. Impact of SARS-CoV-2 on the Mobility Behaviour in Germany. Eur Transp Res Rev. 2021;13(1):10–3. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12544-021-00469-3
Borkowski P, Jażdżewska-Gutta, M, Szmelter-Jarosz A. Lockdowned: Everyday Mobility Changes in Response to COVID-19. J Transp Geogr. 2021;90:102906. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jtrangeo.2020.102906
MOBIS. MOBIS – Mobility Behaviour in Switzerland - Research Project. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://ivtmobis.ethz.ch/mobis/en
COSMO. COSMO – COVID-19 Snapshot Monitoring. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://projekte.uni-erfurt.de/cosmo2020/web
Gummer T, Schmiedeberg C, Bujard M, Christmann P, Hank K, Kunz T, et al. The Impact of COVID-19 on Fieldwork Efforts and Planning in pairfam and FReDA-GGS. Surv Res Methods. 2020;14(2):223–7. https://doi.org/10.18148/srm/2020.v14i2.7740
Scherpenzeel A, Axt K, Bergmann M, Douhou S, Oepen A, Sand G, et al. Collecting Survey Data among the 50+ Population During the COVID-19 Outbreak: The Survey of Health, Ageing and Retirement in Europe (SHARE). Surv Res Methods. 2020;14(2):217–21. https://doi.org/10.18148/srm/2020.v14i2.7738
Hlatshwako TG, Shah SJ, Kosana P, Adebayo E, Hendriks J, Larsson EC, et al. Online Health Survey Research During COVID-19. Lancet Digit Health. 2021;3(2):e76–7. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2589-7500(21)00002-9
Krumpal I. Determinants of Social Desirability Bias in Sensitive Surveys: A Literature Review. Qual Quant. 2013;47(4):2025–47. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11135-011-9640-9
Hipp L, Bünning M, Munnes S, Sauermann A. Problems and Pitfalls of Retrospective Survey Questions in COVID-19 Studies. Surv Res Methods. 2020;14(2):109–14. https://doi.org/10.18148/srm/2020.v14i2.7741
Sastry N, McGonagle K, Fomby P. Effects of the COVID-19 Crisis on Survey Fieldwork: Experience and Lessons from Two Major Supplements to the U.S. Panel Study of Income Dynamics. Surv Res Methods. 2020;14(2):241–5. https://doi.org/10.18148/srm/2020.v14i2.7752
Adams J, White M. Health Behaviours in People Who Respond to a Web-based Survey Advertised on Regional News Media. Eur J Public Health. 2008;18(3):335–8. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurpub/ckm100
Schnell R, Noack M, Torregroza S. Differences in General Health of Internet Users and Non-users and Implications for the Use of Web Surveys. Surv Res Methods. 2017;11(2):105–23. https://doi.org/10.18148/srm/2017.v11i2.6803
Braekman E, Charafeddine R, Demarest S, Drieskens S, Berete F, Gisle L, et al. Comparing Web-based Versus Face-to-face and Paper-and-pencil Questionnaire Data Collected Through Two Belgian Health Surveys. Int J Public Health. 2020;65(1):5–16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00038-019-01327-9
Schaurer I, Weiß B. Investigating Selection Bias of Online Surveys on Coronavirus-related Behavioral Outcomes. Surv Res Methods. 2020;14(2):103–8. https://doi.org/10.18148/srm/2020.v14i2.7751
Santamaria C, Sermi F, Spyratos S, Iacus SM, Annunziato A, Tarchi D, et al. Measuring the Impact of COVID-19 Confinement Measures on Human Mobility Using Mobile Positioning Data. A European Regional Analysis. Saf Sci. 2020;132:104925. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssci.2020.104925
Zhou Y, Xu R, Hu D, Yue Y, Li Q, Xia J. Effects of Human Mobility Restrictions on the Spread of COVID-19 in Shenzhen, China: A Modelling Study Using Mobile Phone Data. Lancet Digit Health. 2020;2(8):417–24. https://doi.org/10.1016/S2589-7500(20)30165-5
Vannoni M, McKee M, Semenza JC, Bonell C, Stuckler D. Using Volunteered Geographic Information to Assess Mobility in the Early Phases of the COVID-19 Pandemic: A Cross-city Time Series Analysis of 41 Cities in 22 Countries from March 2nd to 26th 2020. Glob Health. 2020;16(1):85. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12992-020-00598-9
Kraemer MUG, Yang C-H, Gutierrez B, Wu C-H, Klein B, Pigott DM, et al. The Effect of Human Mobility and Control Measures on the COVID-19 Epidemic in China. Science. 2020;368:493–7. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.abb4218
Google. COVID-19 Community Mobility Reports. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.google.com/covid19/mobility/
Klingwort J, Schnell R. Critical Limitations of Digital Epidemiology: Why COVID-19 Apps Are Useless. Surv Res Methods. 2020;14(2):95–101. https://doi.org/10.18148/srm/2020.v14i2.7726
Blom AG, Wenz A, Cornesse C, Rettig T, Fikel M, Friedel S, et al. Barriers to the Large-scale Adoption of a COVID-19 Contact Tracing App in Germany: Survey Study. J Med Internet Res. 2021;23(3):e23362. https://doi.org/10.2196/23362
González A, von Lücken C, Paciello J, Ocampos T, Pane J. Critical Overview of the Use of Contact Tracing Apps in the Context of the COVID-19 Pandemic. Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Complexity, Future Information Systems and Risk (COMPLEXIS 2021). 2021;91–9. https://doi.org/10.5220/0010480400910099
Möllers A, Specht S, Wessel J. The Impact of the COVID-19 Pandemic and Government Intervention on Active Mobility. Inst Transp Econ Münst. 2021;Working Paper No. 34.
Newlands G, Lutz C, Tamò-Larrieux A, Villaronga EF, Harasgama R, Scheitlin G. Innovation under Pressure: Implications for Data Privacy During the COVID-19 Pandemic. Big Data Soc. 2020;7(2):1–14. https://doi.org/10.1177/2053951720976680
Puts MJH, Daas PJH, Tennekes M, de Blois C. Using Huge Amounts of Road Sensor Data for Official Statistics. AIMS Math. 2019;4(1):12–25. https://doi.org/10.3934/Math.2019.1.12
Nolan L. Developing Timely Statistics in the United Kingdom in Response to the COVID-19 Outbreak. Big Data Matters 3, Statistics Netherlands. 2021.
hystreet GmbH. Methodology. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://hystreet.com/methodology
World Health Organization (WHO). Virtual Press Conference on COVID-19 – 11 March 2020. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.who.int/docs/default-source/coronaviruse/transcripts/who-audio-emergencies-coronavirus-press-conference-full-and-final-11mar2020.pdf?sfvrsn=cb432bb3_2
Kultusministerkonferenz. Entscheidungen der KMK in der Corona-Krise. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.kmk.org/aktuelles/entscheidungen-der-kmk-in-der-corona-krise.html
Kultusministerkonferenz. Zum Umgang mit dem Corona-Virus. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.kmk.org/presse/pressearchiv/mitteilung/detail/News/zum-umgang-mit-dem-corona-virus.html
Hochschulrektorenkonferenz. Auswirkungen der COVID-19-Pandemie auf die deutschen Hochschulen - Aktuelle Hinweise und Nachrichten. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.hrk.de/themen/hochschulsystem/covid-19-pandemie-und-die-hochschulen/
Hochschulrektorenkonferenz. HRK: Sommersemester 2020 weiter als Online-Semester durchführen - Rückkehr zu Präsenzlehre nur schrittweise möglich und sinnvoll. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.hrk.de/presse/pressemitteilungen/pressemitteilung/meldung/hrk-sommersemester-2020-weiter-als-online-semester-durchfuehren-rueckkehr-zu-praesenzlehre-nur-schri/
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Besprechung der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder vom 22.03.2020. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/breg-de/themen/coronavirus/besprechung-der-bundeskanzlerin-mit-den-regierungschefinnen-und-regierungschefs-der-laender-vom-22-03-2020-1733248
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videokonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 15. April 2020. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bmi.bund.de/SharedDocs/downloads/DE/veroeffentlichungen/2020/corona/beschluss-bund-laender-kontaktbeschraenkungen-15-april.pdf?__blob=publicationFile&v=4
Kultusministerkonferenz. Hubig: KMK schafft mit Rahmenkonzept Voraussetzung für schrittweise Schulöffnungen in ganz Deutschland. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.kmk.org/presse/pressearchiv/mitteilung/detail/News/hubig-kmk-schafft-mit-rahmenkonzept-voraussetzung-fuer-schrittweise-schuloeffnungen-in-ganz-deutschla.html
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Pressekonferenz von Bundeskanzlerin Merkel, Ministerpräsident Söder und dem Ersten Bürgermeister Tschentscher im Anschluss an das Gespräch mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/breg-de/aktuelles/pressekonferenzen/pressekonferenz-von-bundeskanzlerin-merkel-ministerpraesident-soeder-und-dem-ersten-buergermeister-tschentscher-im-anschluss-an-das-gespraech-mit-den-regierungschefinnen-und-regierungschefs-der-laender-1751050
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videokonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 28. Oktober 2020. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/breg-de/aktuelles/videokonferenz-der-bundeskanzlerin-mit-den-regierungschefinnen-und-regierungschefs-der-laender-am-28-oktober-2020-1805248
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videokonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 25. November 2020. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/resource/blob/997532/1820090/11c9749f77a71b9439759538864aa672/2020-11-25-mpk-beschluss-data.pdf
Jungblut M. Rückblick 2020 - Chronologie eines Schuljahrs in der Coronakrise. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.deutschlandfunk.de/rueckblick-2020-chronologie-eines-schuljahrs-in-der.680.de.html?dram:article_id=489919
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Telefonkonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 13. Dezember 2020. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/resource/blob/997532/1827366/69441fb68435a7199b3d3a89bff2c0e6/2020-12-13-beschluss-mpk-data.pdf?download=1
Kultusministerkonferenz. Wiederaufnahme des Schulbetriebs - Beschluss der Kultusministerkonferenz vom 04.01.2021. 2020 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.kmk.org/fileadmin/veroeffentlichungen_beschluesse/2021/2021_01_04-Corona-Beschluss-KMK-Schule.pdf
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videoschaltkonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 5. Januar 2021. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/resource/blob/997532/1834306/75346aa9bba1050fec8025b18a4bb1a3/2021-01-05-beschluss-mpk-data.pdf?download=1
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videoschaltkonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 19. Januar 2021. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/resource/blob/997532/1840868/1c68fcd2008b53cf12691162bf20626f/2021-01-19-mpk-data.pdf?download=1
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videoschaltkonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 10. Februar 2021. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundeskanzlerin.de/bkin-de/suche/videoschaltkonferenz-der-bundeskanzlerin-mit-den-regierungschefinnen-und-regierungschefs-der-laender-am-10-februar-2021-1852824
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videoschaltkonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 3. März 2021. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundesregierung.de/resource/blob/997532/1872054/66dba48b5b63d8817615d11edaaed849/2021-03-03-mpk-data.pdf?download=1
Presse- und Informationsamt der Bundesregierung. Videokonferenz der Bundeskanzlerin mit den Regierungschefinnen und Regierungschefs der Länder am 22. März 2021. 2021 [retrieved 2021 Jul 15]. https://www.bundeskanzlerin.de/bkin-de/aktuelles/videokonferenz-der-bundeskanzlerin-mit-den-regierungschefinnen-und-regierungschefs-der-laender-am-22-maerz-2021-stand-24-maerz-2021-1881736
Kitchin R, Stehle S. Can Smart City Data Be Used to Create New Official Statistics? J Off Stat. 2021;37(1):121–47. https://doi.org/doi:10.2478/jos-2021-0006
Bohlen JM, Beal GM. The Diffusion Process. Spec Rep. 1957;18(1):56–77.
Krusina A, Chen O, Varela LO, Doktorchik C, Avati V, Knudsen S, et al. Developing a Data Integrated COVID-19 Tracking System for Decision-Making and Public Use. Int J Popul Data Sci. 2020;5(4):1–10. https://doi.org/10.23889/ijpds.v5i4.1389
Mourby MJ. ‘Leading by Science’ through COVID-19: the GDPR & Automated Decision-Making. Int J Popul Data Sci. 2020;5(4):1–7. https://doi.org/10.23889/ijpds.v5i4.1402
Di Cara NH, Song J, Maggio V, Moreno-Stokoe C, Tanner AR, Woolf B, et al. Mapping Population Vulnerability and Community Support during COVID-19: A Case Study from Wales. Int J Popul Data Sci. 2020;5(4):1–15. https://doi.org/10.23889/ijpds.v5i4.1409
Brocker SA, Klingwort J. Comparing Sensor-based Pedestrian Flows with Survey Estimates of Pandemic-preventing Behavior. In: Data Collection, Measurement, and Public Opinion During a Pandemic 76th Annual Conference American Association for Public Opinion Research (AAPOR). 2021.
Smedley T. Clearing the Air: The Beginning and the End of Air Pollution. New York: Bloomsbury Publishing; 2021.
Lohr SL, Raghunathan TE. Combining Survey Data with Other Data Sources. Stat Sci. 2017;32(2):293–312. https://doi.org/10.1214/16-STS584
Klingwort J, Buelens B, Schnell R. Capture–recapture Techniques for Transport Survey Estimate Adjustment Using Permanently Installed Highway-sensors. Soc Sci Comput Rev. 2021;39(4):527–42. https://doi.org/10.1177/0894439319874684
Datta AR, Ugarte G, Resnick D. Linking Survey Data with Commercial or Administrative Data for Data Quality Assessment. In: Hill CA, Biemer PP, Buskirk TD, Japec L, Kirchner A, Kolenikov S, et al., editors. Big data meets survey science. Wiley; 2020. p. 99–129. https://doi.org/10.1002/9781118976357.ch3
Medalia C, Meyer BD, O’Hara AB, Wu D. Linking Survey and Administrative Data to Measure Income, Inequality, and Mobility. Int J Popul Data Sci. 2019;4(1):1–8. https://doi.org/10.23889/ijpds.v4i1.939
