With tremendous potential for research and policy use, the development of Electronic Medical Record (EMR) is unprecedentedly growing in China. The rich clinical and financial data in the Chinese EMR provides us a unique chance to examine the impacts of health insurance on health care utilization and outcomes, controlling for patient’s disease severity.
Our study population included patients with cirrhosis or primary liver cancer (PLC), from a large teaching hospital in Beijing. The comorbidity and disease severity variables were defined using EMR automated extraction methods that were validated in previous study. Health insurance was measured by actual reimbursement ratio (RR), which better captures patients’ actual financial burden than type of health insurance. Generalized linear regression model was used to analyze the impacts of health insurance coverage on total hospital expense, ratio of medication cost to total expense, and number of major procedures (i.e., transcatheter arterial chemoembolization, TACE) for cirrhosis. Logistic regression was used to assess the impact of health insurance on hospital mortality and the rate of TACE. We employed a wide range of risk factors in our models to adjust for disease severity and comorbidities, including Charlson comorbidities, MELD-Na score, and etiological factors of liver diseases.
In total, 5,465 cirrhosis patients and 3,357 PLC patients were included in the study. Among the PLC patients we identified 534 patients underwent TACE. After adjusted for comorbidities, disease severity and other confounders, RR was found to be associated with hospital mortality with odds ratio 3.2 in cirrhosis patients and 6.0 in PLC patients. Higher RR was correlated to lower total hospital cost (logarithm transferred coefficient -0.08 in cirrhosis patients and -0.15 in PLC patients) but related to higher ratio of medication cost (logarithm transferred coefficient 0.09 in both cirrhosis and PLC patients). Additionally, higher RR was associated with higher rate (odds ratio 1.6 in PLC patients) and also more times of TACE (logarithm transferred coefficient 0.31 in TACE patients). The results were consistent between cirrhosis patients and PLC patients.
This study provided evidences that physicians’ behavior was influenced by health insurance. Patients with more generous health insurance coverage (higher RR) were found to have relatively lower total hospital cost but higher ratio of medication cost, higher rate and more times of TACE, and were more prone to die in hospital. These are evidences for physician’s gaming reacting to the economic incentives of the payment systems in China.
Most read articles by the same author(s)
- Karen Tang, Kelsey Lucyk, Hude Quan, Barriers to high quality coding of hospital chart information to administrative data: A qualitative study , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Mingkai Peng, Danielle Southern, Tyler Williamson, Hude Quan, Under-coding of secondary conditions in coded hospital health data: impact of co-existing conditions, death status and number of codes in a record , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Mingkai Peng, Guanmin Chen, Gilaad Kaplan, Lisa Lix, Neil Drummond, Kelsey Lucyk, Stephanie Garies, Mark Lowerison, Samuel Weibe, Hude Quan, Methods of defining hypertension in electronic medical records: validation against national survey data , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Karen Tang, Hude Quan, Doreen Rabi, Measuring medication adherence: standardized definitions are needed to allow for comparisons , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Danielle Southern, Hude Quan, William Ghali, ICD-11: towards better capture of quality and safety events in hospital , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Yuan Xu, Ning Li, Mingshan Lu, Robert Myers, Elijah Dixon, Robin Walker, Hude Quan, Developing and Validating Electronic Medical Record Based Case Definitions for Liver Diseases and Comorbidities , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Yuan Xu, Mingshan Lu, Elijah Dixon, Robert Myers, Ning Li, Hude Quan, Comparison of Risk Adjustment Methods in Patients with Liver Disease Using Electronic Medical Record , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Kyle Kemp, Maria Santana, Rachel Jolley, Danielle Southern, Hude Quan, Discharge Communication and Patient Involvement are Associated with Unplanned Hospital Readmissions: Results from a Validated Hospital Experience Survey , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Mingkai Peng, Bing Li, Danielle Southern, Hude Quan, Constructing episodes of inpatient care: How to define hospital transfer in hospital administrative health data? , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS
- Lisa Lix, John Paul Kuwornu, George Kephart, Khokan Sikdar, Mark Smith, Kristine Kroeker, Hude Quan, Evaluating the Completness of Physician Billing Claims: A Proof-of-Concept Study , International Journal of Population Data Science: Vol 1 No 1 (2017): IJPDS